Key insights:

1. Shippers on Asia to N. Europe, Mediterranean and US East Coast trade lanes are facing longer transit times and the possibility of empty container shortages in the coming weeks as schedules are revised by diversions away from the Red Sea, though carriers and operators are working to avoid vessel bunching and congestion that could cause further delays.

2.  Higher costs to carriers due to the longer voyages – as well as some possible increase in demand as shippers pull volumes forward to make up for the longer transit times and prepare for the upcoming Lunar New Year – have not led to spiking ocean rates just yet. But widespread Asia - Europe GRIs and surcharges announced for January could push prices up to the $4K - $5k/FEU range.

3. Asia - N. America rates are also likely to climb as some carriers have already announced $500/FEU surcharges across the board and $2,500 increases for India - US East Coast shipments. Some shippers are likely to shift away from the East Coast to avoid delays, which could put pressure on rates to the West Coast as well.

4. These impacts will be felt until carriers return to the Red Sea, but even with the US-led naval coalition in place, attacks have continued. Some carriers say they won’t return even with the naval force in place while Maersk and CMA CGM have already started scheduling some vessels to return to the Red Sea in the coming days and say they intend to go back twill go back but have not given a definite timeline.

1 Ocean delays could lead to some shift to air cargo though so far there have not been reports of an air cargo bump. Freightos Air Index rates for Asia - N. America were level last week, while Asia - N. Europe prices decreased.

Ocean rates - Freightos Baltic Index:

• Asia-US West Coast prices (FBX01 Weekly) increased 7% to $1,659/FEU.

• Asia-US East Coast prices (FBX03 Weekly) were level at $2,505/FEU.

• Asia-N. Europe prices (FBX11 Weekly) increased 11% to $1,621/FEU.

• Asia-Mediterranean prices (FBX13 Weekly) increased 5% to $2,525/FEU.

Air rates - Freightos Air index

• China - N. America weekly prices were level at $5.85/kg.

• China - N. Europe weekly prices fell 17% to $3.97/kg

• N. Europe - N. America weekly prices dipped 6% to $2.09.

Analysis

Widespread carrier diversions away from the Red Sea and Suez Canal to avoid the threat of Houthi attacks are impacting ocean operations for ex-Asia trade to N. Europe, the Mediterranean and North America’s East Coast. Longer transit times have disrupted schedules and have carriers and port operators rushing to revise arrival slot allocations in an attempt to avoid the “vessel bunching” of multiple ships arriving at once that was one driver of port congestion and delays at Europe’s major hubs during the pandemic.

Relatively low container yard density at the moment and lessons learned during COVID will work in favor of ports trying to avoid significant backlogs. Carriers are adding additional vessels to their rotations and are sailing faster to keep up with departure schedules in Asia, but the longer trips will mean more time required to repatriate empty containers and could lead to shortages at Asian origin ports. And if carriers start omitting port calls and offloading containers at alternate destination ports to compensate, these steps could also contribute to delays for shippers and the possibility of congestion at larger hubs.

At the same time, demand may be increasing as shippers start to pull forward volumes to make up for longer transit times and in preparation for China’s Lunar New Year holiday in early February.

Though prices have not spiked just yet, carriers facing higher costs – estimated at as much as $2M per round trip – for longer transits, as well as the possible increase in demand will push ocean rates up significantly in January.

Even before the diversions, carriers had announced plans for January GRIs to elevate Asia - Europe and Mediterranean rates to above $3,000/FEU. The success of those increases would’ve depended on blanked sailings and other capacity reduction measures, which now will be canceled as those extra ships will instead be activated to service the now significantly longer loops.

And on top of the spot rate increases, carriers have announced a deluge of Asia - Europe surcharges – ranging from $500 to more than $2,000 per container depending on the carrier and the specific lane – starting on January 1st to pass costs on to their customers. Taken together, these GRIs and surcharges, if successful, could push spot rates up to the $4K - $5/FEU level while diversions continue.

Asia - N. America operations and rates will likely be impacted as well. Some Asia - US East Coast services, especially from the Indian Subcontinent, typically sail via the Suez Canal and will now divert around the south of Africa. Some carriers have already announced $1,500/FEU GRIs and significant surcharges for India - N. America containers, and $500/FEU surcharges for all transpacific shipments starting in mid-January, though surcharge announcements for N. America have not been widespread so far.

But the number of impacted Asia - N. America vessels will be even higher than usual as several carriers had already rerouted some services – that normally transit the Panama Canal on their way to the East Coast – to the Suez to avoid possible Panama Canal drought-driven delays and extra costs. The US West Coast may also be impacted in the form of an increase in volumes as some shippers are already shifting away from the East Coast to avoid the increase in transit times for time-sensitive shipments.

This upward pressure on rates – which will be welcomed by carriers facing overcapacity and now starting Asia - N. America long-term contract negotiations – is likely to persist until carriers feel comfortable returning to the Red Sea.

Even with the US-led naval coalition in place, attacks have continued. The US has indicated that the naval force will use a defensive strategy to secure the waterway, while the Houthis have threatened to attack US Navy ships if Houthi positions are targeted.

But, with the task force in place, Maersk and CMA CGM have already started scheduling some vessels to return to the Red Sea in the coming days and have announced that they will resume normal operations as soon as possible, though they have not given a definite timeline for a full return. Other carriers like Hapag-Lloyd and MSC, meanwhile, have no plans to return even with the new security measures.

In air cargo, some analysts are expecting the delays in ocean freight to lead to some shift of more urgent volumes to sea-air services or air cargo alternatives. So far there have not been reports of any significant air cargo bump, though. Freightos Air Index rates for Asia - N. America were level last week, while Asia - N. Europe prices decreased.